Tuesday, July 23, 2024

A Petition From The Big Mountain Situation

Ladies & Gentlemen, the Old, the Young, the Coming Generation, and Relatives:

As we speak, there exist a state of fear and anxiety in a traditional community at Big Mountain in the heart of Black Mesa. And as we speak, the federally deputized officers of the BIA Hopi Agency Police and Rangers are patrolling this region where a few traditional elders continue to live and also resist federal mandates to relocate. I want to bring your attention to one particular situation that is an example of the wide-spread acts of injustice, human rights violation, religious intolerance, and threats of property destruction.

Dineh resister and elder, Pauline Whitesinger, has stood her ground since 1977 when the BIA tried to build a range unit fence within the lands partitioned to the neighboring tribe, the (modern and progressive) Hopis. Pauline still believes in the old ways by upholding aboriginal rights and treaty rights and because of BIA-Hopi restriction on new contruction and her deteriorating ceremonial hogan, she replaced and rebuilt a new hogan. The BIA Indian police are constantly taken photographs of her residence, her neighbors that come to see her, her non-Indian volunteer helpers, and her grandchildren that come to visit. The police do not attempt to talk to her or answer to  her concerns and requests.

This area known as the Hopi Partitioned Lands still has Dineh residents and has been made an isolated area, and this is allowing the federal government to do as they please with these last, traditional peoples. Navajo Nation President Joe Shirley, Jr. has even made numerous comments that the Dineh resistance at Big Mountain “a lost cause and a closed case” meaning that these Dineh are to never be thought of, again. Meaning that these Dineh, who are my Big Mountain relatives, need to be erased from the state of the Navajo Nation and perhaps, Pauline is right when she says, “we are in way of Peabody, profit, revenues, and industrial jobs.”

The last few elder resisters and their few supporters (native or non-natives) will continue to provide the much needed humanitarian aide to our surviving history: traditional Dineh living and maintaining on their ancestral and sacred homelands. However, we all need to act in the best means possible and stop the daily Gestapo tactics and the potential demolishment of a sacred hogan or earth lodge. We all need to prevent any harm that may be committed on our elders or their helpers and most of all, prevent this growing hostility from getting out-of-hand.

All legal recourses are no longer an option since this is a challenge against a U.S. Executive Order, and The Peoples are the only option to bring about attention, focus and restoration.

I have attached a petition with addresses of officials and I am making a plead to you all, my relatives, to sign it and either send it directly to the listed officials or send them to the Black Mesa Indigenous Support. This situation is very urgent. These elders are very old now and they truly deserve much honor. They have lived in a way that, we or our future generations may never see humans live in this country. These traditional elders must live their naturally-given, old life in peace and harmony, Hozhon goh. Yaa’at’eeh goh.

I apologize for the long list of officials, but it has become long because of so many years of ignorance and because certain, minor sectors of society believed that these Elders would have been defeated already.

Thank you for your time.

Sincerely & In the Spirit of Chief Barboncito,

Bahe Y. Katenay (Naabaahii Keediniihii)
Dineh of Big Mountain


The Sovereign Nation of the Big Mountain Dineh
VIA Black Mesa, Navajo Indian Reservation, Arizona, U.S.A.

March 2009

Dear Mr. President Barrack Obama, and
Madame Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton,

Copies to:
Mrs. Katherine Smith & Mrs. Pauline Whitesinger, Big Mountain Sovereign Dineh,
Selected Kimongwis of the Independent Pueblo of Hotevilla,
Mr. William Means & Ms. Andrea Carmen, International Indian Treaty Council,
President Joe Shirley, Jr., The Navajo Nation,
Mr. Roman Bitsuie, The Navajo-Hopi Land Commission,
Office of the Hopi Tribe’s Office of Hopi Lands,
Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Phoenix Area Agency
Department of the Interior, Office of Surface Mining

The Sovereign Nation of the Big Mountain Dineh is located in northeastern Arizona on Black
Mesa and is part of ancient indigenous shared-territories. Members of this nation were affected
by the 1974 legislation to relocate from certain partitioned areas, but have rather chose to resist
this policy and try to: maintain their ancestral and treaty lands, keep cultural practices, value
universal-granted freedom, conduct their ancient rights to ritual ceremonies, and preserve their
sacred sites. The proclamation of these Dineh in 1979 states that through divine creation they
were, “provided with the Ni’tliz’ (sacred stones) as offerings and the Dzil leezh (sacred
mountain soil Bundle) representing the universe. With prayers and songs we offer the Ni’tliz to
the trees, to the hills, to the wind, and the thunder beings in the sacred rain. The Dzil Leezh is
our power to live close to our mother the Earth and father Sky. These are our sacred ways to
survive in this universe and to communicate with the unseen forces in the Natural life.”

As you may be aware that, the relocation of thousands of Dineh (Navajos) and Hopis has been in
process since 1977 after 1.8 million acres was partitioned and that, the Dineh elder leaders at Big
Mountain began their resistance to U.S. government court orders to vacant areas partitioned to
the official and federally-recognized, Hopi tribe. These traditional Dineh communities still
continue to resist the harsh relocation policies and coal mining encroachment to this day. Despite
a few elders are now left, they continue to reaffirm their ancestral land rights which are contrary
to all court decisions related to the fore mentioned communities from 1974 to 1998.

U.S. Judicial System has had a vital role in this land rights issue ever since energy companies of
the southwestern United States became interested in exploring the coal reserves of Black Mesa in
northeastern Arizona. In 1962, there was a well-orchestrated rush to establish an Indian Land
Claims on the behalf of the Hopi tribe and which was guided by a Peabody Coal Company
attorney, and this allowed Peabody to acquire mining leases. The U.S. courts and corporate
attorneys eventually, thereafter, help created the relocation and land-partitioning policies which
only made way for coal exploration. None of these court rulings were based on proving that an
actual “land dispute” did exist between the Dineh and Hopis.

Big Mountain on Black Mesa is the only place in the United States where two Indian nations can
still define cultural coexistence and shared territories, and now have become endangered
aboriginal peoples. The U.S. courts have ordered continued pressure on the remaining traditional
Dineh and keep the areas sealed and isolated. The United States is allowing this tragedy and
genocide to be sustained under the guise that relocation are on voluntary basis and that Indian
police are being used rather than state authorities to carry out enforcements. These traditional
resisters hold great knowledge and wisdom of ancient information and natural existence that are
irreplaceable, and it is the world society’s responsibility to stop the United States and its largest
coal-producer, Peabody Energy, from executing this human and mega-environmental

Additional documentations (www.supportblackmesa.org) of human rights violation and religious
intolerance are as follows:
 Limitation or complete denial of: crop cultivation and livestock husbandry, community
and religious activities, access to or maintenance of water wells, and elder residents’
safety needs to attain wood fuels for heating and cooking,
 Forced relocation to foreign settings that does not support or replace loss culture and
 Deliberate breaking up of family and clan structures,
 Controlled national media that portray the Big Mountain story as a result of legitimate
and humane court decisions,
 Peabody mines create: daily detonation that causes micro-quakes, depletion of pristine
aquifers that causes subsidence and fissure zones, and massive emissions of coal dust
and engine exhaust.

We the undersigned hereof state our demand that the United States cease all forcible relocation
enforcements on the Dineh, and reverse the decisions made for Peabody Coal Company’s Life of
the Mine Permit on Black Mesa.
It will be furthered recommended that:
 Indigenous peoples’ inherent rights to their homelands be recognized and respected,
 Traditional tribal communities be allowed to reinstate and restore the inexorable ties to
fundamental existence and spiritual practices,
 There must be serious reviews about the conclusion that Black Mesa coal is the primary
source for energy, and that being reviewed in the context of global concerns for
greenhouse gas emissions,
 Acknowledge that indigenous being has sustained all human cultures’ moral obligations
throughout the ages, and it is much more crucial in this technological era that the
demands and rights of indigenous peoples be received with greater human understanding.

Thank you for your time and consideration.


U.S. President Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500
Phone Numbers:
Comments: 202-456-1111
Switchboard: 202-456-1414
FAX: 202-456-2461

U.S. Secretary of State Clinton

Public Communication Division:
PA/PL, Rm. 2206
U.S. Department of State
2201 C Street NW
Washington, D.C. 20520

Bureau of Indian Affairs
Department of the Interior
1849 C Street, N.W.
Washington DC 20240

Office of Surface Mining
Department of the Interior
1849 C Street, N.W.
Washington DC 20240

Bureau of Indian Affairs

P.O. Box 10
Phoenix, AZ 85001
P: 602/379-6600
F: 602/379-4413
Hopi Agency
Bureau of Indian Affairs
P.O. Box 158
Keams Canyon, AZ 86034
P: 520/738-2228
F: 520/738-5522

Navajo Nation Office of the President
Joe Shirley, Jr.
Communications Director
George Hardeen
Phone: (928) 871-7917
Cell: (928) 309-8532

Staff Assistant
Gloria Bowman
Phone: (928) 871-7915
Fax: (928) 871-7005

Administrative Assistant
Desiree Etsitty
Phone: (928) 871-7916
Fax: (928) 871-7807

Hard Rock Chapter
P.O. Box 20
Kykotsmovi, AZ 86039
Phone: (928) 725-3730/3732
Fax: (928) 725-3731
E-mail: hardrock@navajochapters.org

Forest Lake Chapter
P.O. Box 441
Pinon, AZ 86510
Phone: (928) 677-3252/3347
Fax: (928) 677-3320
E-mail: forestlake@navajochapters.org

Black Mesa Chapter
P.O. Box 189
Pinon, AZ 86510
Phone: (928) 309-7056
E-mail: blackmesa@navajochapters.org
(To traditional Dineh or Hopi Kimongwis, or
other Communiqué to Sovereign Dineh.)

Black Mesa Indigenous Support
P.O. Box 23501
Flagstaff, Arizona 86002
Email: blackmesais@riseup.net

Comments are closed.